Top 10 Best caramels in 2026

Last Updated - 6/12/2026

🏆Best Choice

Taffy Town

Taffy Town Saltwater Taffy- Licorice Swirls | Gourmet Taffy| Nougat-Style Candy| Soft & Delicious| Sumer Snack Treats| Party Good Candies| 2.5lbs

9.8

ChoiceComparer.com Score

9.8

/ 10

Outstanding

Main highlights

•UNIQUELY CRAFTED GOURMET TAFFY: For over 100 years, Taffy Town has been manufacturing gourmet Salt Water Taffy. It is a delicious whipped taffy that melts in your mouth with a wide variety of true to life, unique, and amazing flavors. We make it even better through our 24-hour conditioning and whipping processes to produce its perfect texture.
•ALLERGEN FREE: Everyone can try our delicious taffy treats. Our taffy is Made in the USA in a batch process, using the best ingredients and flavors we can find. Our factory is free of tree nuts, peanuts, and gluten. Kosher certified and we have both regular and sugar free options.
•FLUFFY & CREAMY TEXTURE: All our products contain egg whites and milk for a creamy, melt-in-your-mouth taste and texture that is without comparison!
•PERFECT FOR ANY OCCASIONS: It’s a colorful product with individual wrapping to make it easy to use in candy buffets, holiday treats, summer snacks, party goody bags, and more. It is a fun medium to use for creative decoration projects and crafts for both children and adults!
•80+ TRUE TO LIFE FLAVORS: Whether you like the classics or want to try a new flavor combination, look no further than Taffy Town!

View offer on:

$22.69

Check Price

Gustaf's

Gustaf's Beehive Dutch Licorice Drops - 5.2oz Bag - Sweet Honey Black Licorice Candy - Dutch Candy from Netherlands - Sweet Black Liquorice Treats - Beehive Liqourice with Honey

9.7

ChoiceComparer.com Score

9.7

/ 10

Outstanding

Main highlights

•Sweet Twist for Licorice Lovers – Delight in the unique combination of real licorice and sweet honey flavor with these bee candy drops, a true treat for fans of dutch black licorice.
•Authentic Dutch Licorice – Indulge in Dutch licorice candy from Netherlands, crafted with care to bring you the rich, authentic taste of traditional licorice black.
•Honey-Kissed Licorice – Gustaf’s licorice pairs the bold flavor of classic candy licorice with a touch of natural honey, creating a sweet and rich snacking experience.
•Wholesome and Delicious Ingredients – Made with natural licorice extract, coconut oil, and non-GMO ingredients, this liquorice candy is a quality treat you can feel good about enjoying.
•Perfectly Sized – These bite-sized bee candy drops are conveniently packaged in a 5.2oz bag, making them the ideal liquorice candy to take on the go or enjoy at home.

View offer on:

$5.67

Check Price

Heavenly Caramel

J Morgan Confections Heavenly Caramel | Licorice Flavor | 45 Count Tub | Gourmet Soft and Chewy Butter Caramel Candies | Hand-Crafted Golden Treats

9.5

ChoiceComparer.com Score

9.5

/ 10

Outstanding

Main highlights

•J Morgan Confections Heavenly Caramels, Licorice flavor (1 lb. 2 oz, 45 ct, Single-Pack). Gourmet, artisan soft and chewy butter caramels, individually wrapped. Creamy and smooth old-fashioned caramel candies, small batch hand-crafted golden caramel treats.
•Source – J Morgan has been creating the most delectable and rich specialty confections and truffles for over half a century. Founded in the scenic state of Utah, J Morgan selects only the highest quality ingredients to craft our old-fashioned style gourmet confections. We use an original and authentic caramel recipe and crafting method to create the finest and tastiest sweet caramel candies.
•Process/Flavor – Rich butter, fresh cream and sweet sugar are heated and blended at precise temperatures in small batches to create the most delightful soft and chewy caramel treat. The mixture is stirred until the desired golden color and smooth, creamy consistency is successfully achieved. Flavoring is infused into the mixture as it cools for ultimate flavor retention. The specialty caramel apple flavor is popular for its absolutely scrumptious and mouthwatering taste of caramelized apples.
•Features – Slow caramelization is what makes these unique caramels intensely sweet with an unforgettable melt-in-your-mouth sensation. Our 1-pound, 2-ounce specialty tub contains 45 individually wrapped sweet caramel candies for ultimate convenience and freshness. You’ll find yourself reaching for those creamy caramel treats whenever you’re looking for something satisfying to suck or chew.
•Uses – J Morgan’s Heavenly Caramels make an incredible bite-size treat when you’re in need of something comforting and sweet. These old-fashioned style caramels can be enjoyed as candies, or used for desserts such as cookies, biscuits, caramel pops, bars, pies and cakes. Melt some down as a mouthwatering sauce for homemade caramel-dipped apples or strawberries, or to drizzle on pudding, cheesecake, cupcakes or muffins. Treat someone special with these gourmet treats for a memorable gift.

View offer on:

$20.35

Check Price

Walkers' Nonsuch

Walkers' Nonsuch Liquorice Toffees | with Condensed Milk & Black Treacle | Imported from the UK | Traditional British Candy | Old Fashioned Licorice Toffee | 5.29 Oz (150g)

9.4

ChoiceComparer.com Score

9.4

/ 10

Excellent

Main highlights

•Traditional British Toffee: Enjoy the classic taste of Walkers' Nonsuch Liquorice Toffees, a timeless British confection
•Rich Liquorice Flavor: Infused with the rich and distinctive flavor of real liquorice for an unforgettable taste experience
•High-Quality Ingredients: Made with the finest ingredients, including real butter, to ensure a premium toffee
•Individually Wrapped: Each toffee is individually wrapped to maintain freshness and provide convenient, on-the-go enjoyment
•Perfect for Gifting: An excellent choice for candy lovers and a delightful addition to gift baskets and special occasions
•No Artificial Colors or Preservatives: A natural treat free from artificial colors and preservatives
•Suitable for Vegetarians: Enjoy a delicious treat that aligns with vegetarian dietary preferences
•Handcrafted Excellence: Expertly made by skilled confectioners, ensuring top-notch quality and taste

View offer on:

$7.86

Check Price

Walkers' Nonsuch

Walkers' Nonsuch Liquorice Toffees | with Condensed Milk & Black Treacle | Imported from the UK | Traditional British Candy | Old Fashioned Licorice Toffee | 5.29 Oz (Pack of 2)

9.2

ChoiceComparer.com Score

9.2

/ 10

Excellent

Main highlights

•Traditional British Toffee: Enjoy the classic taste of Walkers' Nonsuch Liquorice Toffees, a timeless British confection.
•Rich Liquorice Flavor: Infused with the rich and distinctive flavor of real liquorice for an unforgettable taste experience.
•High-Quality Ingredients: Made with the finest ingredients, including real butter, to ensure a premium toffee.
•Individually Wrapped: Each toffee is individually wrapped to maintain freshness and provide convenient, on-the-go enjoyment.
•Perfect for Gifting: An excellent choice for candy lovers and a delightful addition to gift baskets and special occasions.
•No Artificial Colors or Preservatives: A natural treat free from artificial colors and preservatives.
•Suitable for Vegetarians: Enjoy a delicious treat that aligns with vegetarian dietary preferences.
•Handcrafted Excellence: Expertly made by skilled confectioners, ensuring top-notch quality and taste.

View offer on:

$14.99

Check Price

SweetGourmet

SweetGourmet Heavenly Soft & Delicious Licorice Caramels | Old-English Candy | 1 Pound

9.1

ChoiceComparer.com Score

9.1

/ 10

Excellent

Main highlights

•BLACK LICORICE: Classic salt licorice candies individually wrapped in white paper for freshness and convenience. Rich butter, fresh cream and sweet sugar are heated and blended at precise temperatures in small batches to create the most delightful soft and chewy caramel treat.
•TRADITIONAL TASTE: Gourmet, artisan soft and chewy butter caramels, individually wrapped. Creamy and smooth old-fashioned caramel candies, small batch hand-crafted caramel treats.
•PREMIUM QUALITY: Each piece is carefully crafted with rich, dark licorice for an intense and satisfying candy experience—an original and authentic caramel recipe and crafting method to create the finest and tastiest sweet caramel candies.
•CONVENIENT PACKAGING: Individually wrapped pieces make these perfect for sharing, storing, or enjoying on-the-go
•GENEROUS SIZE: Each candy piece measures approximately 1 inch in length, providing a substantial treat for licorice lovers. Approximately 40 pieces per pound.

View offer on:

$14.99

Check Price

Heavenly Caramel

J Morgan Confections Heavenly Caramel | Licorice Flavor | 4.7 oz Bag, 4-Pack | Gourmet Soft and Chewy Butter Caramel Candies | Hand-Crafted Golden Treats

8.9

ChoiceComparer.com Score

8.9

/ 10

Great

Main highlights

•J MORGAN CONFECTIONS Heavenly Caramels, Licorice flavor (4.7 oz bag, 4-Pack). Gourmet, artisan soft and chewy butter caramels, individually wrapped. Creamy and smooth old-fashioned caramel candies, small batch hand-crafted golden caramel treats.
•GOURMET TREATS J Morgan has been creating the most delectable and rich specialty confections and truffles for over half a century. Founded in the scenic state of Utah, J Morgan selects only the highest quality ingredients to craft our old-fashioned style gourmet confections. We use an original and authentic caramel recipe and crafting method to create the finest and tastiest sweet caramel candies.
•DELECTABLE FLAVOR Rich butter, fresh cream and sweet sugar are heated at precise temperatures in small batches to create the most delightful soft and chewy caramel treat. The mixture is carefully stirred until the desired golden color and smooth, creamy consistency is achieved. Flavoring is infused into the mixture as it cools for ultimate flavor retention. The Old-English black licorice flavor is popular for its absolutely scrumptious and mouthwatering licorice taste.
•MELT IN YOUR MOUTH Slow caramelization is what makes these unique caramels intensely sweet with an unforgettable melt-in-your-mouth sensation. Each 4.7 oz bag contains a serving of four fresh and soft caramel candies, individually wrapped for ultimate convenience and freshness. You’ll find yourself reaching for those creamy butter caramel treats whenever you’re looking for something satisfying to suck or chew.
•COMFORTING GIFT J Morgan’s Heavenly Caramels make an incredible bite-size treat when you’re in need of something comforting and sweet. Caramels can be enjoyed as candies, or used for desserts such as cookies, biscuits, caramel pops, bars, pies and cakes. Melt some down as a mouthwatering sauce for homemade caramel-dipped apples or strawberries, or to drizzle on pudding, cheesecake, cupcakes or muffins. Treat someone special for a memorable gift!

View offer on:

$28.49

Check Price

Pioneer Valley

Black Licorice Caramels 8oz Box by Pioneer Valley (Soft, Premium Quality)

8.8

ChoiceComparer.com Score

8.8

/ 10

Great

Main highlights

•Pioneer Valley Caramels - for those times when you want a bit of comfort food and deserve a bit of luxury.
•A rich and creamy soft caramel with a smooth black licorice flavor. Creamy caramels with a black licorice flavor so smooth and yummy you'll want to eat piece after piece!
•Made with premium all natural ingredients. We use real cream and real butter. Lots and LOTS of cream and mountains of butter. No funky hydrogenated, vegetable, or tropical oils like cheap caramels.
•Beautiful box perfect gift for all occasions: Mothers’ Day, Fathers’ Day, Christmas, Hostess, Office, Thank You, Business, House Warming, Birthday, etc. Great for Gift Baskets!
•Small family owned and operated business with decades of experience. Our recipes have been passed down and improved over generations. A favorite of craft shows, farmers’ markets and Harvest Festivals.

View offer on:

$9.99

Check Price

Cozy Confections

Heavenly Caramels Individually Wrapped Old English Licorice Caramels, 1 Pound

8.6

ChoiceComparer.com Score

8.6

/ 10

Good

Main highlights

•LICORICE CARAMELS: These licorice caramels combine the rich, creamy texture of caramel with the bold flavor of licorice. Each bite delivers a smooth and chewy experience, blending sweet and slightly salty notes for a unique candy indulgence. The licorice-infused caramel offers a perfect balance of flavors, making it a treat for both licorice lovers and caramel fans alike. These gourmet caramels provide a luxurious and satisfying twist on traditional sweets.
•INDIVIDUALLY WRAPPED: Each piece is carefully wrapped to ensure freshness and convenience, making them perfect for on-the-go snacking.
•ALWAYS FRESH: Our delectable licorice caramels are always fresh, and come in a one-pound resealable bag, ensuring freshness and allowing you to enjoy this irresistible treat at your own pace.

View offer on:

$17.99

Check Price

SweetGourmet

SweetGourmet English Style Salted Licorice Toffees | Individually Wrapped | 1Lb

8.5

ChoiceComparer.com Score

8.5

/ 10

Good

Main highlights

•These plain licorice are very enjoyable. It has that smooth, soft texture with a licorice flavor that is not overpowering. Licorice toffees are a traditional English favorite. They’re creamy and smooth with a mild licorice flavor. This product is non-GMO.
•These small individually wrapped totally black extremely soft pieces will totally satisfy you.
•Unique Sweet Licorice Flavor | Individually Wrapped | Non-GMO |
•Net Wt.: 1LB (16oz). Packed in resealable Zip-Lock Stand Up Pouches.
•Made in Morocco. Distributed and Repackaged by SweetGourmet

View offer on:

$14.59

Check Price

📊

📈 How we rank

With our cutting-edge technology, we examine thousands of products and retailers, assessing reviews, ratings, trends, and sales rankings to identify what matters most to users like you.

Our team evaluates this data alongside genuine user feedback, merging AI analysis with human insights to provide you with real-time, highly-rated recommendations that empower your decision-making with clarity and confidence.